At first I thought they looked like Gallery Mint uniface copies. But now I think they are presentation pieces from a generic replica rarity coin set. The bubbly and rough surface make me think they are silver plated base metal.
Regardless how accurate this assessment is, they are not from the U.S. Mint.
I think MS-63 is fair. I don't see anything remotely close to detailing this coin. $2 is highway robbery, you should track down the seller and give him a few more dollars
Just had a chance to look at it. First impression was 62-63 because of the clean, mark-free appearance but the dulled luster. Would have settled with 63. 62 is still a good grade.
That price certainly feels high. The rarity of the variety in my opinion is close to irrelevant as there are just a handful of collectors that assemble this set by die variety. I would expect a decline in price if it was sold again today.
VF, I would risk only paying cleaned money. Photos are touched up and the lighting could be intentionally concealing reflective and semi-polished surfaces.
It looks to be a lovely MS-63 to me. I say certainly genuine and certainly uncirculated, no doubt about it. Color looks good. Worst case it gets an MS-62.
Post some photos of your coins and we'll tell ya real quick if they are real or not. Much easier than buying a bunch of equipment and watching how-to youtube videos.
If the coin is worth about $20 without the off center, do you think it is worth an extra $405?
My personal opinion who collects early mint errors, the off center is not significant and the coin is in not great condition. Maybe worth $100 in my eyes to the right person. Nevertheless, any degree of off centering is very uncommon on FEC.